Catalan Uprising

Post a reply


This question is a means of preventing automated form submissions by spambots.

BBCode is ON
[img] is OFF
[flash] is OFF
[url] is ON
Smilies are OFF

Topic review
   

Expand view Topic review: Catalan Uprising

Re: Catalan Uprising

by Deano » Sun Dec 24, 2017 5:16 pm

I believe that there should be more governance in regions I think that is the best way forward personally so I support Catalonian independence the same that I support my own country's bid for independence

It's got to be implemented correctly and we shall all see what will happen in Catalonia but until then I wish you all a merry Christmas and a happy New year

Re: Catalan Uprising

by Hjl » Sun Dec 24, 2017 5:07 pm

That's difficult isn't it. What do you do with the nearly 43% who don't want independence? Will they cut the region in half, let the half that want independence live there and the other half live in Spain still? This is a pretty significant example of majority tyranny.

Re: Catalan Uprising

by daib0 » Fri Dec 22, 2017 3:57 pm

CATALONIA ELECTION - 21 December 2017

There is a big problem for PP and Mariano Rajoy now. Beaten out of sight PP were in a night few could have anticipated. Ciudadanos with their rather whinging leader Ines Arrimadas took probably the great part of the PP vote. Both these parties were calling for ‘real’ elections to end the ‘locura’ (“madness” as they put it). So now we have had the supposed real election. Did she (Arrimadas) win? Not really, she managed just 25.4% of the vote. The two last time together united independence parties scored 43.1% of the votes - not double that, but not far off either - but the fact that each of the two big independence parties went separate this time would appear - as least as long as Madrid wants you to believe - that C’s were the great winners. And so they will still claim there is not a majority for independence. The truths are starting to come out now, not even what I feel is the verging of censorship from Spanish mainstream parties can hold the lid down for much longer.

Let’s take a closer look not just at the seats gained, which is obviously without a doubt an Independence majority (and indeed an improvement on last time), but in the actual number of VOTES themselves. Don’t be fooled by fake statements. Let’s look … Comú (Catalonia in Common) are crucial here - the furthest left supposedly national ‘Spanish’ party there is. Although they look after local regional interests they are fairly close cousins with Podemos (ah, the CUP are left-wing too, but are totally nationalist). Remember that Comú support a referendum on independence, even if many of their supporters are divided on whether independence is really a good thing, but in the name of democracy are certainly supportive - also remember that in the declaration of independence this autumn some of their parliamentary members did indeed vote for outright independence on that fateful day. However, seeing as they are not irrevocably nationalist the centralist government in Madrid pleases itself and tries to fool others and casts all those supporter voters as all unionist Spanish constitutionalists - far from the truth, Comú/Podemos are those who wish most to reform the constitution from top to bottom! As Comú/Podemos and their members are therefore divided on the issue, let’s leave them out of the equation. So, what do we in fact have? These based on 99% vote analyzed -

Independence % voters: 53.5%
Spanish Unionist % voters: 43.5%


Now, what were they (PP and C’s) saying about governing for ALL Catalans? OK, let’s see it please!! By not acting for the majority they are supporting a minority like it were a dictatorship. I rest my case…

Re: Catalan Uprising

by bodacious benny » Mon Oct 23, 2017 6:10 am

Hjl wrote:
Bodacious Benny wrote:The world would be far better off if there was an event that wiped out a significant percentage of the human population!

Except if that were the case then odds are you'd be amount the dead....
Well, can't be too choosey!

Re: Catalan Uprising

by Hjl » Mon Oct 23, 2017 1:21 am

Bodacious Benny wrote:The world would be far better off if there was an event that wiped out a significant percentage of the human population!

Except if that were the case then odds are you'd be amount the dead....

Re: Catalan Uprising

by bodacious benny » Sun Oct 22, 2017 10:15 pm

The world would be far better off if there was an event that wiped out a significant percentage of the human population!

Re: Catalan Uprising

by skalpel » Sun Oct 22, 2017 10:07 pm

Hjl wrote:
skalpel wrote:
If there's another world war, you won't have to do any fighting anyway. Just get a really good spade and lots of tinned food.
Think I might move to Kenya
I'll be in Shackleton's Hut, best wishes.

Re: Catalan Uprising

by Hjl » Sun Oct 22, 2017 9:52 pm

skalpel wrote:
Hjl wrote:I'd like to hope that we don't descend into another world war. There are a lot of far wing politicians around at the moment in Europe and around the world, the difference now I suppose is that the vast majority of people are still moderate and have access to the Internet. It should be far harder to pull the wool over the eyes of such a huge population.

I have no interest in fighting if there is a war. I've said for a while that the solution to warfare is to make the leaders of the countries lead from the front. Amazing how unappealing a war is if you are the one who has to die in it.
If there's another world war, you won't have to do any fighting anyway. Just get a really good spade and lots of tinned food.
Think I might move to Kenya

Re: Catalan Uprising

by skalpel » Sun Oct 22, 2017 9:50 pm

Hjl wrote:I'd like to hope that we don't descend into another world war. There are a lot of far wing politicians around at the moment in Europe and around the world, the difference now I suppose is that the vast majority of people are still moderate and have access to the Internet. It should be far harder to pull the wool over the eyes of such a huge population.

I have no interest in fighting if there is a war. I've said for a while that the solution to warfare is to make the leaders of the countries lead from the front. Amazing how unappealing a war is if you are the one who has to die in it.
If there's another world war, you won't have to do any fighting anyway. Just get a really good spade and lots of tinned food.

Re: Catalan Uprising

by Hjl » Sun Oct 22, 2017 9:48 pm

I'd like to hope that we don't descend into another world war. There are a lot of far wing politicians around at the moment in Europe and around the world, the difference now I suppose is that the vast majority of people are still moderate and have access to the Internet. It should be far harder to pull the wool over the eyes of such a huge population.

I have no interest in fighting if there is a war. I've said for a while that the solution to warfare is to make the leaders of the countries lead from the front. Amazing how unappealing a war is if you are the one who has to die in it.

Re: Catalan Uprising

by Sir Bobby » Sun Oct 22, 2017 9:05 pm

Magdia wrote:It always used to comfort me to think that we are completely different to the societies of 100-150 years ago and couldn't possibly fall into the same catastrophes they did...

Then I remember that they always thought the concert of Europe would hold, The Franco Prussian war/American civil war/Ruso-Japanese wars were humanitarian disasters never to be repeated and they thought they were civilised <erk>

We are different but never far from disaster.
We’re basically all just glorified chimps that decided to cover our generals really. I don’t understand why people think we’ve evolved beyond certain things, like racism for example. Sure, our IQs have gone up but we’re still massively governed by biases and emotions.

Re: Catalan Uprising

by Blue & Maroon » Sun Oct 22, 2017 8:38 pm

It always used to comfort me to think that we are completely different to the societies of 100-150 years ago and couldn't possibly fall into the same catastrophes they did...

Then I remember that they always thought the concert of Europe would hold, The Franco Prussian war/American civil war/Ruso-Japanese wars were humanitarian disasters never to be repeated and they thought they were civilised <erk>

We are different but never far from disaster.

Re: Catalan Uprising

by skalpel » Sun Oct 22, 2017 11:30 am

Most periods of reshuffle at the top end of power have been ugly all round and then escalated to conflict at the top until a relative peace settles under a new world order. (Seven Years War, Revolutions & Napoleonic Wars followed by Pax Britannica, then the First and Second World Wars followed by Pax Americana etc.) So far, at least, nothing on such an explosive scale has happened, but the world is such an enormously different place now that it's hard to say whether that would be even how it would play out. I suppose it's arguable that we've entered a long period of constant warfare around the globe which won't have a conclusion in the same way as war once did. Maybe that's what world war is now, I dunno.

Re: Catalan Uprising

by bodacious benny » Sun Oct 22, 2017 11:08 am

Aldridge Prior wrote:
Bodacious Benny wrote:It's quite good that we're not the only European country f***ing things up.
The scary thing is that this kind of widespread discontent is exactly what acted as a catalyst to both world wars.

There's so much awful s*** going on all over the world right now it's almost like something's gotta give.
Oh yeah, totally feels like a lot of societies around the world are at tipping point. Something's going to give sooner or later.

Re: Catalan Uprising

by Aldridge Prior » Sun Oct 22, 2017 10:54 am

Bodacious Benny wrote:It's quite good that we're not the only European country f***ing things up.
The scary thing is that this kind of widespread discontent is exactly what acted as a catalyst to both world wars.

There's so much awful s*** going on all over the world right now it's almost like something's gotta give.

Re: Catalan Uprising

by bodacious benny » Sat Oct 21, 2017 11:10 pm

It's quite good that we're not the only European country f***ing things up.

Re: Catalan Uprising

by daib0 » Sat Oct 21, 2017 10:11 pm

BBC News

Catalonia independence: Puigdemont 'will not accept' Rajoy plan

Starts: Catalan leader Carles Puigdemont says Catalonia will not accept Madrid's plan to impose direct rule on the region. He described it as the worst attack on Catalonia's institutions since General Franco's 1939-1975 dictatorship, under which regional autonomy was dissolved. Spanish PM Mariano Rajoy's plans include the removal of Catalonia's leaders and curbs on its parliament.

Complete article:

Re: Catalan Uprising

by daib0 » Tue Oct 03, 2017 12:15 pm

by the way, Pique booed fiercely at Spain's training camp. He was in tears afterwards...

Re: Catalan Uprising

by Blue & Maroon » Mon Oct 02, 2017 4:31 pm

How to fail at stopping an independence movement 101. Spanish government has essentially supplied the Catalan government with rocket fuel.

Re: Catalan Uprising

by Micky Quim » Mon Oct 02, 2017 4:11 pm

Those videos are horrendous. Never seen Police brutality like that before. Shocking

Top